Fat Body Positivity is in trouble

Published 2.7.2024: I have written here quite a bit about so-called Body Positivity, what I like to call FAT Body Positivity (FaBoPo) because it is my observation that many of the Body Positivity supporters really only mean fat bodies. Thin bodies are considered standard, and well represented in the mainstream. Which I has a nugget of truth in it, but completely ignores the fact that people in bodies of all sizes have issues.

The term "Body Positivity" therefore has fallen out of fashion, and now the preferred term is Fat Activist (FA). I think it's a better term, because it makes it plain that the movement is for, and limited to, fat bodies. And I can respect that. It's not for me (or my daughter) and so I can ignore it. But as FAs have aged, a number of them have begun to lose weight (intentionally, which is taboo) and even with the new weight loss drugs. Holy hell, even Tess Holiday is on a diet. I don't watch Tess Holiday's content, I learned of this news from this YouTuber (whom I have highlighted previously.) I don't disagree with her assessment in this case, and will suggest that you watch her video.

Of course, there's been a backlash, especially from younger fat activists. To be honest, I feel like I've witnessed this before (yes, I'm old). Every generation's fat activists reach a point where (if they have exceeded their own body's ability to compensate) where they decide to lose weight or otherwise "get healthy." And in the time of Ozempic™ and other GLP-1 drugs, this is particularly a fraught time for FAs because now there is a medicated way to lose weight. Note: Tess Holiday did NOT say that she was on weight loss drugs, just that she was eating an "anti-inflammatory" diet (which looked for all the world like a diet plate. Again, I'm old and I've seen diet plates. I know the tricks to make a little bit of food look like a lot of food. Tess Holiday is dieting to lose weight.).

To be clear, I'll restate my position again. I am not an FA ally, because I think that weight and health are related. I do NOT think that there is a particular size that anyone has to be, I think that it's very individual. Each body has an amount of weight for which it can compensate. That means you may well be able to carry an amount of weight that the BMI scale would designate as obese and be quite healthy. However, once you exceed the amount of weight your body can compensate for, health issues begin. And (again I'm OLD), my observation is that the amount of excess weight the body can healthily compensate for declines with age. So the 50-75 extra pounds that you have at 20 hits differently when you're 50 or 60. Now add that fact that for most FAs the only direction of weight change that's valid is increase, and your weight at 60 is probably more than your weight at 20. And the weight at 60 is tougher to decrease at 60— though both weight gain and loss is still possible.

The problem for some (many?) of these FAs is that they aren't carrying 50 pounds (23 kilograms) in excess weight, they are carrying 100+ pounds (45+ kilograms) of excess weights. Which means they reach the point where their bodies can't compensate at a much younger age. And some of them don't survive. Although the deaths are seldom noted in FA circles, the various deaths have begun to be a topic in the wider arena.

There are negatives to the drugs, but GLP-1 drugs are good for more than weight loss… and also, only a very little weight loss is required for the body to re-establish equilibrium. So you don't have to lose the extra 100+ pounds, you just need to lose a percentage of the weight. The body wants to heal, and the human body is amazing.

This article is supposed to be a conversation between Hanna Rosin and Olga Khazan about Ozempic™ and its effects on FA, but continues the fallacy that fat people don't eat more than normal weight people. This insistence that fat doesn't result from overeating is just nonsense. Sure, there are drugs that increases the relative ease of getting fat, but most people get fat the old fashion way, they eat more food than they expend and gain weight. On social media there are people documenting their lives, and getting fatter and fatter. It's very clear why, they are eating too much.

At least the article acknowledges that there are health issues to be overweight. I would word that differently… as I did above. Obesity was declared a disease in 2013, paving the way for weight loss drugs. Noom (the weight loss service) also offers GLP-!s, just as Weight Watchers does, which I didn't know. The fact that Weight Watchers offers GLP-!s is taken as an admission that it failed.

Interestingly, they go over the positives about GLP-1s, and then the negatives. In this article the fact that obesity is considered a disease is thought to be a positive development. I still maintain that obesity is not a disease, but the fact that it's considered one means that insurance companies will choose to cover the new drugs.

I want to end with an observation about lymphedema, which a number of the larger FAs have. There is no cure for lymphedema, and no one know precisely what causes it. But my observation is that it doesn't arise unless the body's weight has exceeded the body's ability to compensate for the excess weight. There may be cases where always thin people get the disease, but I think it's far more prevalent in fat people. Sadly, once it happens, there doesn't really seem to be a way to reverse the condition. It seems to improve with weight loss, but I don't know of any sufferers who have gotten rid of it.

I feel like I've seen this movie before, the only difference is the weight loss drugs, which seem (at least at this point) for be safer than past drugs. Not surprisingly, the dangers of new weight loss drugs is one reason that FAs oppose them. GLP-1s are not new, and have been used to treat type 2 diabetes for years. Their use for reversing obesity is new. This being the age of social media, there are channels documenting their progress using the drugs to lose weight.

Will there be another generation of FA after the current generation either dies or loses weight? Time will tell, but if the drugs prove to be successful and prices come down, I think the days of bodies out growing their ability to compensate may be over. NOTE: This doesn't mean that their won't be fat people, it just means that there will be healthier people, who may be a bit smaller than currently.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more here.